The Perfect Football Party Pie

Ashley Cook January 24, 2014 2
The Perfect Football Party Pie

With NFL playoff season in full swing, lots of us are making plans to get together with friends to watch the Puppy Bowl Big Game. While the menu at gatherings like this typically consists of pizza, wings, and jalapeno poppers, vegans need not miss out on all the fun! Why not bring along a fun, football-themed treat to share?

Enter The Perfect Football Party Pie.

Football Pie 001This pie is so super-easy to make!  All you need to do is combine your favorite recipe for a vegan graham cracker crust and your favorite recipe for a vegan pumpkin pie filling.  I snagged both from this recipe for Pumpkin Pie Squares with Graham Cracker Crust from Angela Liddon’s blog, Oh She Glows.




Football Pie 002Bake your pie filling on top of your crust, and after it has cooled and set (be warned that this likely will require it to be chilled overnight), carefully remove it from the pan and set it on top of a piece of parchment paper on a sturdy cutting board.




Football Pie 004

Next, slowly and carefully cut off two of the corners in sort of a rounded boomerang shape until you have a football! 

For the laces, you can use storebought vegan whipped topping, or make coconut whipped cream like I did, and just pipe it right on there! I followed the method described in this tutorial for Coconut Whipped Cream, also by Angela Liddon.


Football Pie 007I can assure you, it’s worth the effort!  But if vegan whipped cream is not in the cards, I bet storebought vanilla frosting would also work.  I recommend serving any excess whipped cream in a bowl alongside the pie so that people can add more as desired to individual slices.

One note: I had trouble finding vegan graham crackers (i.e., ones made without honey) and didn’t feel like (or really have time for) making my own, so I actually ended up going with a vanilla cookie crust instead.


Football Pie 017

All I did was sub in Mi-Del Vanilla Snaps for the graham crackers in the recipe. The flavor and texture went perfectly with the filling! I bet chocolate or ginger cookies would taste great too.

This really is a dish that will be appreciated by a mixed crowd. I brought it to a tailgate for a playoff game last weekend and it was a huge hit with everyone, regardless of dietary preference.  So enjoy, and happy viewing!

Email this to someoneShare on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterPin on PinterestShare on YummlyShare on StumbleUponShare on RedditShare on TumblrDigg thisShare on Google+Print this page


  1. Zyxomma January 26, 2014 at 7:07 pm -

    No football in my future, but the cake will be. I often bake vegan pumpkin panna cotta (pumpkin pie sans crust), so this should be a breeze! Health and peace.

  2. Steve Cook January 28, 2014 at 11:13 am -

    Graham crackers are one of my faves, but as you said the honey is a problem. I’m sure the Vanilla crackers are a good substitute.

Leave A Response »